Skip to Content

Book Review: Black Elk Speaks by John G. Neihardt

Skyblue Overland may earn a small commission from affiliate links in this article.

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Black Elk Speaks is a profound memoir chronicling the life and visions of Lakota holy man Nicholas Black Elk. It explores Native American spirituality, culture, and history, offering timeless insights into humanity’s connection with the natural world.


Black Elk Speaks is a profoundly influential work that transcends the boundaries of memoir, history, and spiritual testament. Chronicling the life and visionary experiences of Nicholas Black Elk, a renowned Oglala Lakota healer and holy man, this book offers a window into a pivotal time in Native American history while revealing deeper truths about humanity’s connection to the Earth. First published in 1932, this narrative has grown into an American classic, lauded for its rich depiction of Lakota culture and spirituality. Its universal themes, combined with the personal tragedy and resilience of Black Elk’s life, ensure its place as a foundational work in Native American literature.



Historical and Cultural Context

Black Elk Speaks is set against the backdrop of the turbulent late 19th century, a time when the Lakota people and other Plains tribes were witnessing the destruction of their way of life. The U.S. government’s systematic campaign of violence and displacement, culminating in the infamous massacre at Wounded Knee in 1890, deeply scarred Black Elk and his people. Black Elk, born in 1863, lived through these tumultuous years. As a child, he witnessed the Battle of Little Bighorn and later fought in several skirmishes, only to see his people crushed under the weight of the U.S. military machine.

But Black Elk’s story is not merely one of political and physical struggle. It is also deeply spiritual. The heart of the narrative lies in Black Elk’s mystical visions, which he experienced throughout his life and interpreted as divine messages about the unity of all living beings. His visions were not just personal experiences but had significant implications for the Lakota people, particularly as they tried to make sense of their plight in the face of overwhelming forces.

The Relationship Between Neihardt and Black Elk

The collaboration between John G. Neihardt, a respected poet and writer, and Black Elk is a key component of Black Elk Speaks. In 1930, Neihardt traveled to the Pine Ridge Reservation in South Dakota to speak with Black Elk, who was then an elder. Recognizing the importance of Black Elk’s story, Neihardt meticulously transcribed the holy man’s words, shaping them into a cohesive narrative that has since moved readers around the world.

Though Neihardt’s role as the intermediary cannot be understated, it is essential to understand the dynamics at play in this collaboration. Neihardt was a white man translating the experiences of a Native American holy man for a primarily non-Native audience. Some scholars have raised concerns about the extent to which Neihardt’s interpretations influenced the story, potentially shaping Black Elk’s words to fit a Western literary tradition or spiritual sensibility. Nonetheless, the book has remained a respected and powerful account, largely because it is deeply rooted in Black Elk’s own voice and vision.

Black Elk’s Visionary Experiences

At the heart of Black Elk Speaks are Black Elk’s visions, which occupy a significant portion of the narrative. At a young age, Black Elk experienced a life-changing vision in which he was transported to the spirit world. There, he met six grandfathers who represented the powers of the universe, and he was given the sacred responsibility of uniting his people and helping them restore balance to the world. This vision is imbued with powerful imagery, blending elements of Lakota cosmology with universal themes of life, death, and the interconnectedness of all living things.

One of the most striking aspects of Black Elk’s visions is their ecological sensitivity. Long before environmentalism became a global movement, Black Elk recognized the deep bond between humanity and the natural world. His vision of a world in balance, where humans and nature coexist in harmony, resonates strongly in today’s age of climate crisis and environmental degradation.

Black Elk’s spiritual journey is also marked by sorrow. He grapples with the knowledge that he was unable to fulfill the grand mission bestowed upon him by the spirit world. As he grows older and witnesses the continued suffering of his people, Black Elk’s sense of failure and disillusionment deepens. This personal tragedy, set against the broader backdrop of the Lakota people’s struggles, adds emotional weight to the narrative.

A Spiritual Testament

More than just a historical account, Black Elk Speaks serves as a spiritual testament that transcends time and culture. Black Elk’s vision of a unified world, in which all living beings are connected by the sacred hoop of life, speaks to universal truths that resonate across cultures. His deep connection to the Earth and his understanding of the cyclical nature of life make his story profoundly relevant in an age where many feel increasingly disconnected from the natural world.

It is this spiritual dimension that has made Black Elk Speaks an enduring classic. Black Elk’s teachings about humility, interconnectedness, and respect for all living things have inspired generations of readers. His story continues to be a source of guidance and wisdom for those seeking a deeper understanding of life’s mysteries and humanity’s place in the world.

Criticism and Scholarly Debate

While Black Elk Speaks is widely celebrated, it has also sparked debate among scholars and Native communities. One of the central criticisms of the work concerns Neihardt’s role as the editor and narrator of Black Elk’s story. Some scholars argue that Neihardt may have unintentionally (or intentionally) imposed a Christian or Western spiritual framework onto Black Elk’s visions, thus altering their original meaning. This critique is especially relevant considering that Black Elk himself converted to Catholicism later in life, a fact that complicates the narrative’s portrayal of him as a purely Lakota spiritual figure.

Moreover, Black Elk’s decision to share his story with Neihardt—a white outsider—has led some to question the authenticity of the account. Did Black Elk alter his story to appeal to a Western audience? Or did Neihardt embellish certain aspects to make the narrative more palatable or marketable? These are complex questions with no definitive answers, but they underscore the challenges of cross-cultural storytelling, particularly when the storyteller comes from a marginalized or colonized community.

Nonetheless, Black Elk Speaks remains a valuable and irreplaceable text. The book provides a rare, first-hand account of Lakota life during a time of immense change, offering readers a window into the spiritual and cultural world of a Native American people. The inclusion of essays and annotations by scholars like Vine Deloria Jr. and Raymond J. DeMallie in the complete edition adds further depth and context, allowing readers to engage with the text on multiple levels.

Conclusion

Black Elk Speaks is more than a historical memoir; it is a spiritual and cultural epic that carries profound lessons for readers of all backgrounds. Nicholas Black Elk’s vision of a world where all living beings are interconnected resonates deeply in our current age of environmental and social crisis. His life, marked by both triumph and tragedy, is a testament to the resilience of the human spirit and the enduring wisdom of Indigenous cultures.

Through John G. Neihardt’s careful transcription, Black Elk’s voice continues to speak across generations, offering hope, guidance, and a call to action for all those who seek to live in harmony with the Earth and each other. The book’s lasting relevance is a testament to its power, ensuring that it will continue to inspire and enlighten readers for many years to come.

Get your own copy of Black Elk Speaks

What to Read Next:

Hike to Black Elk Peak: South Dakota’s Highest Summit

Rediscover Timeless Elegance: The Block Tower System by Barebones

An Adventurer’s Guide to Elk Island National Park in Alberta, Canada

Unprecedented Warnings Issued in Estes Park After Third Elk Stomping Incident

Nocs Provisions 8×25 Binocs – Ultimate Outdoor Accessory